Mike Caldwell spent years turning digital currency into physical coins. That may sound like a paradox. But it’s true. He takes bitcoins — the world’s most popular digital currency — and then he mints them here in the physical world. If you added up all the bitcoins Caldwell has minted on behalf of his customers, they would be worth about $82 million.
Basically, these physical bitcoins are novelty items. But by moving the digital currency into the physical realm, he also prevents hackers from stealing the stuff via an online attack. Or at least he did. His run as the premiere bitcoin minter may be at an end. Caldwell has been put on notice by the feds.
Just before Thanksgiving, he says, he received a letter from the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, or FINCEN, the arm of the Treasury Department that dictates how the nation’s anti-money-laundering and financial crime regulations are interpreted. According to FINCEN, Caldwell needs to rethink his business. “They considered my activity to be money transmitting, ” Caldwell says. And if you want to transmit money, you must first jump through a lot of state and federal regulatory hoops Caldwell hasn’t jumped through.
Caldwell has stopped taking orders for his popular Casascius bitcoins, which have become one of the most recognizable images of the thoroughly intangible digital currency
Because the process is so complicated, Caldwell has stopped taking orders for his popular Casascius bitcoins — which have become one of the most recognizable images of the thoroughly intangible digital currency. In recent months, the feds have cracked down on many other bitcoin operations in similar ways, including Mt. Gox, the most prominent online bitcoin exchange. But Caldwell’s case is a little different. He doesn’t think he transmits money.
Caldwell doesn’t accept U.S. dollars or any type of fiat currency. You send him bitcoins via the internet, and he sends you back metal coins via the U.S. Postal Service. To spend bitcoins, you need a secret digital key — a string of numbers and letters — and when Caldwell makes the coins, he hides this key behind a tamper-resistant strip.
So long as you can keep your Casascius bitcoins safe, nobody can learn the key. To date, Caldwell has minted nearly 90, 000 bitcoins in various denominations. That’s worth about $82 million at today’s exchange rate.
Caldwell takes a fee of about $50 on each coin he mints, but he argues that sending the coins through the mail is not a way of transmitting money. He thinks the coins should be viewed as collectibles.
But, clearly, that’s not how the federal government sees things. If he doesn’t verify or have a way of knowing whether the owner of the bitcoins is the same person he’s sending the coins to, that’s a problem, says Faisal Islam, the director of compliance advisory services with Centra Payments Solutions, a company that advises corporations on financial compliance.
Running afoul of FINCEN is a risky proposition. In the spring, the Department of Homeland Security seized two bank accounts belonging to Mt. Gox. The reasoning behind the $5 million seizure: Mt. Gox, like Caldwell, hadn’t registered itself as a money transmission business. FINCEN did not return a message left by WIRED on Wednesday, but according to the letter it sent to Caldwell, dated Nov. 15, the agency believes that Caldwell’s business is a “money services business, ” that must be registered with FINCEN.
Because he runs a bitcoin-only business, Caldwell says there’s no Casascius bank account for authorities to seize. But he adds that he has no desire to anger the feds, whether he agrees with them or not. So he’s cranking out his last few orders and talking to his lawyer. He says this may spell the end of Casascius coins. “It’s possible. I haven’t come to a final conclusion, ” he says.
Noah Luis, another virtual currency coin-maker who produces metal litecoins as well as bitcoins, says he has talked to Caldwell and is carefully watching his case. Luis and his company, Lealana, isn’t registered as a money services provider — like Caldwell, he doesn’t believe that swapping bitcoins for bitcoins qualifies — but he says he’d probably follow Caldwell’s lead if he receives a similar letter. “I’d probably stop production and sales, just to be safe, ” he says.Who are the league one tricks Tips on what pros do in rainbow six siege List five tips when passing another vehicle: Tips on how to retain information better what does puto mean How to clean a waffle iron? What tricks can i teach my kitten? How to make easy cool tricks what does lavender look like How to train your dragon hiccup How do you do tricks in srl races in destiny How long did it take to build the ark How to do tricks on potty racers game How to skip songs with airpods pro How to turn off flashlight on iphone 13? what does b12 do for the body what does delightful mean what are mothballs used for How to pass a hair drug test 2021 How to get rid of fruit flies in house what are rhetorical choices How would you plate chicken fricassee, tourne potatoes, and aparagus tips what does blown mean What are some tips for creating good resumes what foods are not allowed on the mediterranean diet How to tell strong acids and bases tricks How to make a ringtone what does snarky mean How to make dandelion tea? Tips and tricks on how to construction what does biotin do for hair What vitamin are you lacking when tips of fingers crack Where to park fourth of july santa barbara hints tricks tips what does oscar mike mean what time does on my block come out what does the space stone do How to get my instagram account back What happened to sandra on new tricks!!!!! How to cut up a mango How to make pumpkin seeds How to roast pumpkin seeds what does reps mean How to store avocado? How to play left right center? How to teach a cat cool tricks What are the three dirty tricks the gods played on the takers what does hyaluronic acid do what does histamine do How to dye clothes what are mongols How to get rid of dark circles? How to shrink pores on face? what does rc stand for what are some good movies to watch How to download apps on firestick How to know if you have food poisoning Tips on how to write an informative essay How to lose weight after pregnancy what does smog mean what does tc mean How many people score aht tricks a year How to make my penis bigger? How to get divorced How to lose weight in a month? How to connect ps4 controller to pc what does whitelisted mean in minecraft what time does the raiders play Tips on how to persuade mothers Tips on how to use the t in boston what does ui mean How to negotiate a job offer? what does getting railed mean what does sx mean in medical terms what does pus in urine look like what does ruddy mean How to do a money order? what does chlamydia urine smell like Why were q tips called baby gays what does 4lifers mean what do square waves mean what are the top 10 blood thinners How does doug aldrich do whammy tricks and bombs on a les paul what does b12 do for you what does ywca stand for How long can the tips of steel tip darts be what does pickles mean How to butterfly knife tricks begineer How long to cook frozen chicken in instant pot? How to cut up a mango? How to level ground for pool? what does keal mean what does dnf mean on tiktok How to core a tomato what does figurative language mean How to make a pie crust? How to give tips in a restaurant what are soul ties in the bible what does mmorpg stand for How to download roblox on chromebook How to factory reset a chromebook? what does kk mean How many exemptions on taxes tips secrets How to get a new title for a car? what kind of dog are you what does kindred spirit mean How to register for covid vaccine in ny? what are side effects what does jehovah jireh mean How to get rid of rats outside How to keep cut apples from turning brown? what does cnc mean sexually How to increase bench press? what do ellipses mean How to treat chafing in groin area male? what do the colors of the pride flag mean How long does it take to grow a christmas tree How to stop diarrhea in dogs? How long will it take me to get to work? what does drip mean in slang what is og mean How to say okay in spanish How bank pays the tips restaurant How to dispose of old paint what does an elevated alkaline phosphatase mean How to ride your man How to make a paper sword? How to update graphics card what color does blue and orange make How to send large files How to clean earwax out of ears? what does abound mean what does diminished mean Plaid 2 n 1 craft tool how to change the tips what does edd stand for what does a purple butterfly mean what does a scratchy throat feel like How a tips bond works what does fbo mean cars what does salaam alaikum mean How to know if i have covid? what does the word benevolent mean Linus tech tips how to replace ram How to measure women's waist How to transfer data from iphone to android When it tips over its insides spill out pokemon what does communication mean How to do tricks with 2.4ghz 4ch r/c leason drone Why did ivan leave linus tech tips what are the types of hazards defined by industrial hygiene Why do the tips of my house plant turn brown what are blueberries good for what does it mean when you see a red bird How to send a follow up email after an interview what does karat mean in gold what does a white dove symbolize what do the emojis mean on snapchat How to boil the perfect egg How to make stone in little alchemy 2? what car does emma chamberlain drive what stores are open new year's eve How to find inverse How long for antibiotics to work? How to start your own business A wrner brothers cartoon where a cat tricks another cat into catching mice cause he is too lazy what does adultery mean what do my dreams mean How to lay vinyl plank flooring? what does probe mean Sewing tricks when sewing 2 pieces of lycra fabric together Tips from women who started career in 40s what does it mean if you have diarrhea How to jigsaw puzzle tips what does the moon tarot card mean What is i called when you get acrylic without nail tips what does 777 mean in love Atm machine tricks for when being robbed How to get kidney stones? what are constitutional isomers How long did it take to clean up 9/11 Tips on how to install mannington adura max lvt what does a pussy feel like How to thicken a sauce How to watch halloween kills what are you grateful for today How do you get crediy card tips to subtract from close of day on squsre pos How to style straight hair Tips on how to win 218 on candy crush what does dub mean How long does it take to get a bachelor degree? what does canoodle mean How to cook beef liver How to heal chafing overnight Mx vs atv supercross encore how to tricks Where can i get my childs duke tips seventh grade sat test results How to say mom in spanish? what does gw mean what does t or d mean what are the chances of getting covid again What are some bike tricks Tips on how to be a good frost in rainbow six seige How to stop smoke alarm from chirping What are some tricks that can help track down pesky little bugs When can i teach my puppy tricks what does out for delivery mean usps what are babyback ribs what does marie mean How to calculate sq ft what does the root greg mean what does 64 mean How to braid short hair? what does alterations mean what time does the bears game start what time does walgreens open up what does f i r e mean Tips to prevent skin cancer and what to look for what does cherry chapstick mean slang How to tell if your phone has viruses Tips on the road when sleeping what does sly mean what does organic mean How to fold filter tips Tips for finding your glasses when you can't see what does antithesis mean what does miercoles mean in spanish what does nana mean How to get hair dye off sink How to wash ruggable? How to evolve magikarp? what does cheers mean in england What is state wages tips etc How to stop runny nose fast How to record teams meeting How to close the fnvedit tips menu At what age can you start training a puppy tricks at what temp does water freeze How to make a potion of invisibility How to sync fitbit to iphone what does duality mean How to get more iron? Where to get tips for chrome what does adaptation mean Why pay tips after in usa? How to heal a bone bruise fast How to get hair dye off sink? Jake paul videos with when he tricks everybody that eric was pregnant but she's willing up How to watch dune? How to make buffalo sauce? what does word mean in texting what does rgb mean How to make cinnamon toast How to add bcc in outlook what does crunchy mom mean Yo yo tricks how long has it been what does authorization mean How to check if someone is in jail? what does lactose free mean How to cook shrimp on stove? what does deductible mean Tips on how to get cheap flights How long to grill potatoes in foil? what does he/him/his mean in a signature How to make peach cobbler? How to get rid of calluses on feet overnight How to apply nail tips and dip powder How to set up new iphone? How to register a service dog?